Skip to main content

Lens Sharpness

Lesson 54 from: Fundamentals of Photography 2016

John Greengo

buy this class

$00

$00
Sale Ends Soon!

starting under

$13/month*

Unlock this classplus 2200+ more >

Lesson Info

54. Lens Sharpness

Next Lesson: Camera Movement

Lessons

Class Trailer
1

Class Introduction

17:26
2

Welcome to Photography

13:08
3

Camera Types Overview

02:00
4

Viewing Systems

28:43
5

Viewing Systems Q&A

08:45
6

Lens Systems

32:06
7

Shutter Systems

13:17
8

Shutter Speeds

10:47
9

Choosing a Shutter Speed

31:30
10

Shutter Speeds for Handholding

08:36
11

Shutter Speed Pop Quiz

09:06
12

Camera Settings

25:35
13

General Camera Q&A

14:38
14

Sensor Sizes: The Basics

15:33
15

Sensor Sizes: Compared

19:10
16

Pixels

20:13
17

ISO

21:13
18

Sensor Q&A

13:34
19

Focal Length: Overview

11:09
20

Focal Length: Angle of View

15:09
21

Wide Angle Lenses

08:48
22

Telephoto Lenses

25:23
23

Angle of View Q&A

09:29
24

Fish Eye Lenses

10:39
25

Tilt & Shift Lenses

23:42
26

Subject Zone

17:19
27

Lens Speed

09:56
28

Aperture Basics

08:46
29

Depth of Field

21:49
30

Aperture Pop Quiz

13:23
31

Lens Quality

18:30
32

Photo Equipment Life Cycle

03:57
33

Light Meter Basics

09:25
34

Histogram

15:25
35

Histogram Pop Quiz and Q&A

10:58
36

Dynamic Range

06:03
37

Exposure Modes

15:58
38

Manual Exposure

09:38
39

Sunny 16 Rule

05:54
40

Exposure Bracketing

10:18
41

Exposure Values

27:21
42

Exposure Pop Quiz

26:43
43

Focus Overview

16:15
44

Focusing Systems

05:15
45

Autofocus Controls

11:56
46

Focus Points

07:35
47

Autofocusing on Subjects

20:19
48

Manual Focus

07:52
49

Digital Focusing Assistance

03:40
50

Focus Options: DSLR and Mirrorless

04:58
51

Shutter Speeds for Sharpness and DoF

05:20
52

Depth of Field Pop Quiz

12:14
53

Depth of Field Camera Features

04:54
54

Lens Sharpness

09:58
55

Camera Movement

05:20
56

Handheld and Tripod Focusing

04:32
57

Advanced Techniques

07:12
58

Hyperfocal Distance

06:50
59

Hyperfocal Quiz and Focusing Formula

04:36
60

Micro adjust and AF Fine Tune

05:34
61

Focus Stacking and Post Sharpening

06:00
62

Focus Problem Pop Quiz

18:07
63

The Gadget Bag: Camera Accessories

25:30
64

The Gadget Bag: Lens Accessories

12:46
65

The Gadget Bag: Neutral Density Filter

20:43
66

The Gadget Bag: Lens Hood and Teleconverters

08:55
67

The Gadget Bag: Lens Adapters

05:43
68

The Gadget Bag: Lens Cleaning Supplies

04:34
69

The Gadget Bag: Macro Lenses and Accessories

15:57
70

The Gadget Bag: Flash and Lighting

05:08
71

The Gadget Bag: Tripods and Accessories

18:50
72

The Gadget Bag: Custom Cases

11:20
73

10 Thoughts on Being a Photographer

07:37
74

Direct Sunlight

25:04
75

Indirect Sunlight

18:49
76

Sunrise and Sunset

18:39
77

Cloud Light

14:48
78

Golden Hour

09:50
79

Light Pop Quiz

07:53
80

Light Management

14:00
81

Artificial Light

13:56
82

Speedlights

16:02
83

Off-Camera Flash

27:38
84

Advanced Flash Techniques

09:49
85

Editing Overview

08:24
86

Editing Set-up

08:06
87

Importing Images

16:45
88

Best Use of Files and Folders

20:54
89

Culling

20:56
90

Develop: Fixing in Lightroom

18:13
91

Develop: Treating Your Images

10:53
92

Develop: Optimizing in Lightroom

14:51
93

Art of Editing Q&A

06:01
94

Composition Overview

06:53
95

Photographic Intrusions

10:10
96

Mystery and Working the Scene

16:18
97

Point of View

09:11
98

Better Backgrounds

16:02
99

Unique Perspective

11:02
100

Angle of View

15:06
101

Subject Placement

41:14
102

Subject Placement Q&A

05:18
103

Panorama

07:39
104

Multishot Techniques

13:57
105

Timelapse

16:13
106

Human Vision vs The Camera

20:07
107

Visual Perception

08:35
108

Visual Balance Test

22:56
109

Visual Drama

12:25
110

Elements of Design

28:57
111

The Photographic Process

12:28
112

Working the Shot

27:38
113

The Moment

04:42
114

One Hour Photo - Colby Brown

1:04:32
115

One Hour Photo - John Keatley

1:03:05
116

One Hour Photo - Art Wolfe

59:01
117

One Hour Photo - Rocco Ancora

1:01:20
118

One Hour Photo - Mike Hagen

1:01:20
119

One Hour Photo - Lisa Carney

1:00:52
120

One Hour Photo - Ian Shive

1:08:00
121

One Hour Photo - Sandra Coan

1:10:29
122

One Hour Photo - Daniel Gregory

1:06:07
123

One Hour Photo - Scott Robert Lim

1:05:41

Lesson Info

Lens Sharpness

Let's go to the next section on lens sharpness. So sometimes people are wondering about lenses and this is a good question that somebody who is brand new to photography, think how confused they would be. Nikon makes an 18 to 55, and they make a 17 to 55. Doesn't that seem a little redundant, having two lenses that are so very, very close? Now anyone who uses Nikon will be quickly able to identify that one of these lenses is a lot more expensive, a lot higher quality, and has a lot different characteristics than the other, but for just the focal length, these do about the same thing. I'm not gonna tell you which one's higher quality, but I'm gonna let you guess, okay? It has something to do with the size, but that's because it's letting in more light and it's a lot better constructed. So, for Nikon and Canon one of the tell-tale signs of their higher end lenses with Nikon are their 'N' lenses that have their nano coating. They also put some gold stripes, although it's not meaning anythi...

ng in exact particular, but they tend to put that on some of their higher end lenses. Canon, of course, has their L Series, which they deem their professional series, which are typically built a little bit stronger, tougher, often with weather resistance, often with exotic glass, good manual focus rings and a host of other features that professionals appreciate and they have that red stripe on it. So, jumping back real quickly to the aperture section when we were talking what's the best aperture to shoot at. So when you were judging your photographs looking at the aperture data as to, what aperture did I shoot that photograph at? And the ones in the middle are going to have the sharpest focus, and so the middle of the range for whatever lens that you happen to have. Which is why kinda as a default I would be shooting at f/8 on most of my lenses, and that's kind of the default position, and then if I need shallower depth of field, or more depth of field I will do that without hesitation, but I know I will only go as far as I need to so I only stray from the middle as far as I need to aesthetically in the photograph. There is a way of testing lens sharpness, with something called the MTF Chart, and what this does is grades the sharpness in a variety of ways, in a variety of locations on the sensor. This is a MTF Chart for a lens that is really, really good. Here is a MTF Chart for a lens that is not so good, and you'll have to look at exactly who's making the chart, as to what each of the lines mean, but in general, the zero line along the bottom axis is indicating the middle of the frame. Over on the right, you can see it goes to 20, and it's about 24 millimeters to the edge in the corner of a full framed sensor, and this is telling you the sharpness over in the corner. And if you recall earlier I mentioned that lenses are sharpest in the middle, and this is proof of it, because this is the middle, this is the corner of the frame out here. This is about the vertical and horizontal side out here somewhere. Now, these each of these lines is designating a different type of sharpness. Everything above .6 is considered to be reasonably sharp. Everything above .8 is considered to be very sharp. So you can see in the example on the left, everything from the middle to the corner is very sharp. On the right one, it's sharp in the middle, but but by the time you get to the corners it's going to be soft. Now we have different types of lines, dotted and dashed, and different colored lines and you're going to have to check the actual charts that you look at because each company does their own colors and codings for it. But one of the ways they'll test it is shooting their lens wide open at 2.8 for instance. They might also test it at its peak sharpness of f/8. They might test it with different lines of resolution, how tight is that resolution? And then they might check with the direction of the lines, maybe the sensor is able to pick up more data, lines going one direction versus lines not doing the other direction. I look at all of this and I just kind of forget about it, and I just look at the general flow of lines on the chart to kind of get a feel. The closer it is to the top of the chart, the better it is. And so a bunch of MTF charts for a bunch of lenses that are out on the market right now. And so, if you have a desire to have a perfect lens, this will show you that you are not going to get a perfect lens. Some of the lenses are very nice, that one in the upper top left, the Cannon 500 f/4, that's going to be one of the best lenses that you can get. Now a little bit of word of warning on these MTF charts is that most of the ones that you will ever see are not based in reality. They're based in theory on this optical formula, with this compound, in this setup, this is the results they will get. And so this is not actual testing from the lens. And so the lens that you buy might be a little bit better, might be a little worse. And then we also have sample variation, where you might have the same lens as your friend, but you're getting different quality results from it, because there are slightly different tolerances. Ones just fit the tolerance a little bit better, or yours might have fallen out of tolerance a little bit. So there's a number of things that can affect the sharpness of a lens. One of the places to go if you want to check to see how good a lens, is DXO Mark. They do testing of different lenses. And if you're ever curious about what are the best lenses out there, let me share with you, and there's a few different ways of calculating this so there is some argument to be made here. But with Canon, here is a list of their top five lenses. And look at those lenses and see if you see something common about those lenses. There's no zooms in those choices right there. Let me show you three of the worst rated Canon lenses. One of the things you'll notice there is: A. They're all zooms and there are zooms that have a fairly big range to them as well. Let's take a look at Nikon. What are their five best ranked lenses? And I say there are a number of ways that you can rank them because you can test different cameras and so forth. And this is one of several different ways of calibrating and rating them. And the three worst of the Cannon lenses are once again fairly large zoom lenses. So if you remember my optical hierarchy from the previous class, it very much follows in this and that's where I get that optical hierarchy. You're going to typically get the sharpest lenses in a short to medium telephoto lens. That's just easiest optical place to make a lens, because once you start making wide angles, you start having to deal with distortion, which is very difficult. So it's impressive to see that they have a 24 in there. Fairly impressive to see the 35 is in one way's Canon's technically best lens, and that is certainly not their most expensive lens. Let's take a look at some of the other manufacturers. So with Sony, they have, well they are kind of working with a number of different systems here. And on this one, some of the lenses will work with some systems and some will not. Let's see, let's double check on that, or wait, did I, nope, I'm sorry. I pulled all the lenses for just their full frame mirrorless because that seems to be the system they are using the most now. And so, they don't have many to chose from, but once again, they are all prime lenses on their best. And on their worst lenses, they are all zoom lenses with a fairly large zoom range, and a fairly slow aperture as well. And some of the Micro 4/3 lenses, looking at both Panasonic and Olympus. Once again, prime lenses, fairly fast apertures. The lowest quality lenses, zooms with variable apertures. Now what does this really mean? Well it's kind of fun to look at data, see this ones here, this one's there. Does that mean you shouldn't buy one of these lenses? Does this mean one of these lenses won't fit your needs and your quality standards? Well you're going to have to really test it and see. Because to be honest with you, I own a lens that's on the bottom of the list. It fits my other needs and I'm fine with it. And there just really isn't a faster, better option that does exactly what that lens does. But if you're kind of wondering why do I always get better results with this lens than this lens? One of those things you can go and check out. Alright, let's take a look at some overall lenses, kind of with all different camera systems. Here is overall the sharpest lens you can buy, not going into the medium format, is the Carl Zeiss 55 millimeter Otus lens. This is a $5,000 normal 50 millimeter lens. And it's huge, and it's heavy, and it's something that probably nobody wants to do travel photography with because it is a gigantic, it's like a shot put on the front of your camera. It's so heavy, but it is incredibly sharp. And that is a balance that we all have to make as to how big a piece of equipment we want to put on our cameras. And that has been one of the trends of the last few years, is we have higher quality cameras, with higher quality sensors, and those who are very picky, those pixel people out there are having to get some very large pieces of equipment that are very expense to really maximize that 50 megapixel sensor in some cases. And then once again on the low end big zooms, slow apertures. Olympus makes a body cap which is almost like a joke lens but it's kind of fun. But that's in there and so thinking about lens sharpness. Some things to think about there.

Class Materials

Free Download

Fundamentals of Photography Outline

Bonus Materials with Purchase

Learning Project Videos
Learning Projects PDF
Slides for The Camera Lessons 1-13
Slides for The Sensor Lessons 14-18
Slides for The Lens Lessons 19-31
Slides for The Exposure Lessons 32-42
Slides for Focus Lessons 43-62
Slides for The Gadget Bag Lessons 63-72
Slides for Light Lesson 73-84
Slides for the Art of Edit Lessons 85-93
Slides for Composition Lesson 94-105
Slides for Photographic Vision Lessons 106-113

Ratings and Reviews

a Creativelive Student
 

Love love all John Greengo classes! Wish to have had him decades ago with this info, but no internet then!! John is the greatest photography teacher I have seen out there, and I watch a lot of Creative Live classes and folks on YouTube too. John is so detailed and there are a ton of ah ha moments for me and I know lots of others. I think I own 4 John Greengo classes so far and want to add this one and Travel Photography!! I just drop everything to watch John on Creative Live. I wish sometime soon he would teach a Lightroom class and his knowledge on photography post editing.!!! That would probably take a LOT OF TIME but I know John would explain it soooooo good, like he does all his Photography classes!! Thank you Creative Live for having such a wonderful instructor with John Greengo!! Make more classes John, for just love them and soak it up! There is soooo much to learn and sometimes just so overwhelming. Is there anyway you might do a Motivation class!!?? Like do this button for this day, and try this technique for a week, or post this subject for this week, etc. Motivation and inspiration, and playing around with what you teach, needed so much and would be so fun.!! Just saying??? Awaiting gadgets class now, while waiting for lunch break to be over. All the filters and gadgets, oh my. Thank you thank you for all you teach John, You are truly a wonderful wonderful instructor and I would highly recommend folks listening and buying your classes.

Eve
 

I don't think that adjectives like beautiful, fantastic or excellent can describe the course and classes with John Greengo well enough. I've just bought my first camera and I am a total amateur but I fell in love with photography while watching the classes with John. It is fun, clear, understandable, entertaining, informative and and and. He is not only a fabulous photographer but a great teacher as well. Easy to follow, clear explanations and fantastic visuals. The only disadvantage I can list here that he is sooooo good that keeps me from going out to shoot as I am just glued to the screen. :-) Don't miss it and well worth the money invested! Thank you John!

Vlad Chiriacescu
 

Wow! John is THE best teacher I have ever had the pleasure of learning from, and this is the most comprehensive, eloquent and fun course I have ever taken (online or off). If you're even / / interested in photography, take this course as soon as possible! You might find out that taking great photos requires much more work than you're willing to invest, or you might get so excited learning from John that you'll start taking your camera with you EVERYWHERE. At the very least, you'll learn the fundamental inner workings and techniques that WILL help you get a better photo. Worried about the cost? Well, I've taken courses that are twice as expensive that offer less than maybe a tenth of the value. You'll be much better off investing in this course than a new camera or a new lens. I cannot reccomend John and this course enough!

Student Work

RELATED ARTICLES

RELATED ARTICLES