Creative costumes are pretty much always a Halloween hit — especially if they’re topical, involve a pun, or are otherwise a little outside the box — but before the days of pop-up Halloween stores and online ordering, costumes were creative because they had to be. Whether it was a crafty mom who was especially adept at the sewing machine, or clever kids who put in the work on found objects and cardboard, the Halloween costumes of previous eras involved a lot of innovative thinking and handiwork.

They were also, as evidenced by these vintage Halloween pictures, sometimes supremely creepy and weird to the modern eye. Or, in other instances, rather nonsensical.

Check out these old-timey Halloween pictures and try to guess what the costume is supposed to be, and what the wearers made them out of.

vintage halloween pictures
Photo via Flickr

Clowns — now widely believed to be one of the scarier Halloween costuming options — were still pretty beloved in the 1950s. As a result, clown costumes are popular in these vintage Halloween pictures. Animal masks were also fairly accessible and affordable, making them easy picks.

vintage halloween costumes
Photo via the Library of Virginia

More clowns, plus a few brides and some ballerinas in this 1959 class photo.

vintage halloween pictures
Photo via the Jewish Historical Society

The caption for this photo reads “Lambs, clowns and cowboys are lined up to celebrate Halloween.”

tbt halloween
Photo via Flickr

Pirate costumes were also popular because they essentially only required an eye-patch.

tbt halloween photos
Photo via Flickr

…Or a pipe, if you were this child, dressed as Popeye.

vintage dog photos
Photo via Flickr

And you thought pet costumers were a new trend. This photo of a little dog in a sailor suit is dated 1953!

vintage halloween photos
Photo via Florida Memory

Space-related things were extremely popular following the 1969 moon landing, which could explain the high number of robots, aliens, and possibly even rocket ships among this Fort Lauderdale class in 1970.

vintage halloween costumes
Photo via Flickr

What do we think these New Jersey residents in 1918 were trying to be?